Talk:Robert/@comment-29941366-20200331134955/@comment-29941366-20200331152947

I guess that would make the best compromise. Though then I would also remove all "Sexuality: unknown" entries from other pages and only fill them in once definitive data is available.

Maybe you could even add a "speculation" or "theories" page, where all theories (orientation related and otherwise) can be discussed in the comments and then written down in a short and orderly way, once a concensus has been reached and there is enough evidence gathered to support it, sorted by the current chapter. It could be interesting for readers who find the comic at a later point and are up to date, to look back on what other's have talked about when the plot was at a specific point. This would also encourage theorycrafting, where other's gather evidence for one person's theory to build it out further, or connect two ideas to form a bigger one.

For example, I would have choosen the "gay *" label for Piet over any polysexual label (bi, pan, omni, etc), because of his intimate encounter with Lukas and the implied uneasiness when kissing a girl in the recent flashback, which could have also just been interpreted as normal teenage confusion. But if there were other instances that support my interpretation or go against it, I'd say that would be relevant enough to be written down on the theory page.

However, all that doesn't show up on the character's page, except for maybe a link to the respective part of the theory page.

I'll make a forum post about this later, so others could also comment on whether they would be interested in a theory discussion and archive space.